Repair Requests After Inspection in Texas: Fix It, Credit It, or Refuse It

Repair Requests After Inspection in Texas: Fix It, Credit It, or Refuse It

Hey, it's Eric.

If you are trying to sell my house McAllen and the buyer inspection just came back with a long list, take a breath. Repair requests after inspection in Texas are normal, and not every item on that list has the same weight. Some items can stop a loan. Some are safety issues you should take seriously. Some are cosmetic wishes that belong in a negotiation, not a panic. I am a realtor McAllen TX, and this is how I help sellers in McAllen, Edinburg, Mission, Pharr, Weslaco, and San Juan sort the list into fix it, credit it, or refuse it.

Repair requests after inspection in Texas start with sorting, not reacting

In Texas, the buyer usually has an option period to inspect and negotiate. What you agree to should be in writing in an amendment. Do not rely on a verbal promise, and do not start work until you know what is required, what is negotiable, and what deadline you are working under.

Start by sorting every request into three buckets.

  • Lender required or safety related items that could block financing or closing
  • Functional problems that are real, but where a credit may work better than a rushed repair
  • Cosmetic or upgrade requests that do not affect safety, function, or loan approval

That matters because conventional, cash, and FHA or VA buyers face different rules. I covered the loan side in Repairs a Buyer Lender Will Demand: FHA and VA Condition Fixes Before Closing. Read that before you assume every inspection item is optional.

The lender required repair categories for FHA and VA buyers

FHA and VA appraisers and lenders look for health, safety, and soundness issues. In my experience, these are the categories that most often become lender required, meaning the loan may not close until they are corrected and sometimes reinspected.

  • Roof: active leaks, missing shingles in a way that exposes the home, or a roof at the end of its life with damage that lets water in
  • AC and heat: a system that does not cool or heat, or does not work at all, matters a lot in South Texas heat
  • Water heater: leaking, missing safety features, improper venting, or no hot water
  • Electrical and plumbing: exposed wiring, double tapped breakers that create a hazard, major leaks, or fixtures that do not work
  • Structure and access: broken windows, missing handrails on steps where required, peeling paint on older homes, and doors that do not secure the home
  • Water intrusion and wood damage: active leaks, rot, or pest damage that affects the structure

If an FHA or VA appraiser conditions the loan on a repair, refusing it usually does not make it go away. The buyer may not be able to close, and the next FHA or VA buyer may raise the same item. Fixing it correctly, with receipts and photos, is often the cleanest path. Conventional loans are usually less strict, but an appraiser can still call out safety problems. Cash buyers have no lender, so their requests are pure negotiation.

Cosmetic asks are different, and you can say no

Not every line on an inspection report is a defect that needs a seller repair. Inspectors note everything, including items that are working but old, or purely cosmetic.

Examples include minor drywall cracks, worn paint, older but working appliances, small caulk gaps, and requests to replace a working system just because it is older. Those are not the same as a leaking roof or a dead AC. You can refuse cosmetic asks, offer a small credit, or leave them alone, especially if your price already reflects the condition. I explain that choice in Should You Sell Your House As Is or Make Repairs? An RGV Seller's Guide.

Repair Requests After Inspection in Texas infographic

Dollar ranges for the common Valley items: roof, AC, and water heater

These are example ranges in my experience in the Valley, not quotes. Get a licensed contractor bid before you agree, because size and access change the price.

  • Roof: a small leak repair or limited shingle repair might be in the 350 dollar to 900 dollar range as an example. A larger section repair could be 1,200 dollars to 3,500 dollars. A full replacement on a typical Valley home is a much bigger number, often discussed in the 9,000 dollar to 18,000 dollar range or more depending on size and material. Never credit a full roof price for a small repair without a bid.
  • AC: a service call and minor repair might be in the 250 dollar to 750 dollar range as an example. A major component repair could be 900 dollars to 2,500 dollars. A full system replacement is often discussed in the 6,500 dollar to 12,000 dollar range or more depending on tonnage and efficiency. In our heat, a working AC is not cosmetic.
  • Water heater: a minor fix like an element or valve might be in the 200 dollar to 500 dollar range as an example. A standard replacement, installed, is often discussed in the 1,200 dollar to 2,200 dollar range depending on size, location, and code updates.

Use those ranges to sanity check a request. If a buyer asks for 15,000 dollars for a minor roof leak with no bid, ask for the bid.

Fix it, credit it, or refuse it: how to decide

Fix it when the item is lender required, safety related, or cheap to fix well before closing, and when a credit would still leave the lender condition open. Get it done early, keep invoices, and take before and after photos.

Credit it when the item is real and functional, but the buyer would rather choose their own contractor or upgrade, and the lender will accept a credit instead of a completed repair. Put the exact credit amount in the amendment. Remember, some lenders limit credits or will not allow a credit to replace a required repair, so confirm with the lender first.

Refuse it when the item is cosmetic, working as intended, already disclosed, or priced into the home. Be polite and clear, and keep the door open on the items you will handle. A flat no on everything can kill a deal that a focused yes would save.

Before the inspection ever happens, a pre listing look can save stress. I walk through that in The Pre Listing Inspection: Smart Move or Waste of Money?. Knowing your roof, AC, and water heater condition before you list gives you bids in hand instead of surprises under deadline.

One more rule: never agree to an open ended promise like seller will fix all inspection items. Agree only to a specific list, with a specific standard, by a specific date. If a repair needs a licensed contractor, say so in writing.

The best time to sell a house in Texas is not ruined by an inspection list. What matters is how you sort it. Fix what blocks the loan and what is unsafe, credit what is real but better handled by the buyer, and refuse the cosmetic extras with confidence. That is how to sell your house fast in Texas without giving away your equity one vague request at a time, and it starts with knowing what is my McAllen home worth before you negotiate.

Looking to buy or sell in the Rio Grande Valley?

Eric Jimenez | Eric Real Estate Group, LLC | 956-292-4500 | eric@bettercalleric.com | bettercalleric.com

Better Call Eric. Listings that sell.

Start Your Search: Rio Grande Valley Homes for Sale

Reading about the market is smart. Looking at real homes is better. Try one of these searches, then create a free account to save your favorites and get new listings emailed to you the moment they hit the market.

See a home you like? Call Eric Jimenez at 956-292-4500 and I will set up a showing.